Wednesday, December 23, 2009

We can generate our own economic avenues

EXPLOITATION - ZAHID SAMOON



I sometimes wonder why we protest on trivial issues and ignore the most vital ones, and not fight against the injustice done to out state, time and again. Why are we lip-locked over the successive failure of state governments to address the economical issues concerning the very existence and development of J & K. Political parties keep reciting the exploitation issues when they are out of power but don’t put in enough efforts to resolve them when in power. Why doesn’t our political leadership along with ruling and non-ruling political parties come together to find a solution to our economic dependence on central aids. Why can’t we generate our own economic avenues? Why don’t we fight for our legitimate right over our natural resources?
Jammu and Kashmir has been bestowed best from the bounties of Mother Nature. It is rich in vast renewable as well as non renewable resources. But these resources have remained untapped due to prevailing political unrest as well as lack of proper leadership to address state’s economical issues. Our State has largely remained dependent on the central aids and meager amount of revenue generated from tourism and other allied sectors. Successive state governments have been unable to devise a viable economic strategy to tap vast natural resources. Even though some political parties are voicing their concern over the exploitation of our water resources by the central government, but they have not been able to create a common consensus within regional parties.
When it comes to Indo-Pak relations, Kashmir issue has remained at the top of their agenda. Yet both countries have exploited Kashmir’s water resources without giving an equal share to the residents of their respective parts of Kashmir. Both India and Pakistan still are agrarian based economies, with a large share of their GDP coming from the agriculture sector. Both countries have been trying to make maximum use of the water resources for irrigation purposes. Along with agriculture, water has come up as a source of renewable hydro electric power. Both countries have remained hostile to each other for last 60 years, with little success in resolving their mutual conflicts over different issues. The only success they have attained is through the distribution of their river waters. The Indus Water Treaty (1960) between India and Pakistan is one of the few examples in South Asia, where both countries worked maturely to address the water sharing conflict. Under the Indus Water Treaty, Pakistan has exclusive right over three rivers-Indus, Jhelum and Chenab while India has exclusive right over Sutlej, Ravi and Beas. India has successfully put the rivers in her lap, to generate good amount of hydroelectric power as well as create excellent irrigational facilities in Indian plains. The Treaty fixed and delimited the rights and obligations of India and Pakistan in context of the distribution of Indus water System. The treaty deprived our state to use its own water resources and became one of the reasons for the alienation of people and has severely affected the economic development in the state.
Our politicians haven’t shown enough maturity to negotiate terms with central government. They haven’t even protested for the vandalism of our environment through the central projects. The state incurs losses estimated at Rs 6500 crore annually by the dint of Indus Water Treaty. There are losses in agricultural sector as well as in the generation of hydro-electric power which has otherwise an estimated potential of 20,000 MW. Our politicians should understand that mere passive shouting will not do. They will have to come forward, join hands with each other and consult economic experts to find a way forward.
I have time and again put forward the negative impact of Kishenganga Dam on our environment in front of respected readers. But the time to enumerate the negative impact of the Kishenganga Dam is over. We need to take some practical steps. The politicians have to come above party lines and address the issue of water exploitation with central Government. The work on 330-MW project, with an upgradable capacity of 990 MW, started in 1994. Pakistan has protested since the inception of this project, prompting talks between India and Pakistan. Pakistan alleges that Kishenganga (tributary of Jhelum River) will adversely affect its agriculture and hydroelectric project on river Neelum/Kishenganga across LOC. India redesigned the project in 2006, which has converted it from a storage project to a ‘run-of-river plant. But still India is going to construct a Dam which will inundate 1/3rd of the Gurez Valley. Many Villages will be submerged in the Waters, including the Badwan Village, Nile, Kanzalwan, etc. The Dam will change the climatic conditions of the area and will be detrimental for the sustenance of human as well as wild life in the remote Gurez Valley. Experts say Kishenganga Dam will also affect the fragile ecology of the place and will also disturb the Geological processes. Further it will increase the intensity of the cold waves and agriculture will be badly affected.
Many separatist political parties have voiced their concern over the exploitation of our water resources. Recently PDP – a regional party of Kashmir has voiced its concern over the construction of Kishenganga Dam in Gurez and losses due to Indus water treaty. And in recent Assembly session Local MLA of Gurez (from NC) had voiced the concerns of Gurez People against Kishenganga Dam in Assembly hall. He even described the Indus Water Treaty as Symbol of Slavery!
It is being felt by all the individuals, leaders and politicians that we have been on the losing side for last 49 years, since the inception of the Indus water treaty. But we have not been able to put our point clearly in front of the central Government. Why should we get only 12% Royalty on all central projects? Our environment, natural resources and our development is at stake. Why should we lose 6500 crores every year due to an unjust treaty between India and Pakistan? Why is J&K silent over such a crucial issue? Our intellectuals need to create mass awareness in this regard. Our researchers and economists need to device a comprehensive economic strategy to uplift our state from Backwardness and break the shackles of ignorance.

Friday, August 1, 2008

Sharda University ruins

“Building the past” Sharda University
By Zahid Samoon (Abraham).


This refers to the recent photo exhibition on Sharda Peeth ruins by Ayaz Rasool Nazki (Jammu, 5th April) & subsequent indication given by the Governor Lt. General (Retd) S K Sinha about setting up of Sharda Peeth University in Kashmir. I congratulate Mr. Nazki for holding photo exhibition on Sharda Peeth temple which is just a step towards understanding & reviving our lost heritage. Sharada Peeth has the historic Value because of the Sharda University that once prevailed there. Sharda University was the seat of highest learning in the whole Asia. People across the globe came here to get knowledge & went back to spread that knowledge throughout the Globe.
Sharada Peeth was the famous temple in
Kashmir on the banks of Kishenganga river, (also known as Neelum in Pakistan administered Kashmir). Its ruins are now in Pakistan administered Kashmir near the Line of Control (LOC). Being a Part of the Gurais, Neelum Valley emerged as a different name after the partition of the subcontinent in 1947. Before partition pandits from all over India came to visit this temple for pilgrimage in Gurais. Presently Sharda Peeth is only eight kilometers from the last village of Gurais (Tara Bal) near L.O.C. Many Pandit Brethren are demanding the opening of the route along the L.O.C. through Gurais, as it is the shortest possible distance. And also it is the ancient route to reach the Sharda Peeth. Sharda Peeth is more than140km from Muzaffarabad city. One of the archaeological sites of importance in the Gurez Valley include Kanzalwan where the last council of Buddhism is believed to have been held (in old chronicles its name is mentioned as Kundhalwan) and, further down stream, 8 Km’s away from Bagtore, the ruins of the ancient Sharada Peeth (now under Pakistan's occupation) are preserved along the Kishenganga River.
There is a temple in Kaloosa also named as Sharda temple; besides Bandipora area has the river Madhumati which has the religious importance for Hindus of the area. River mahumati has been mentioned in many ancient chronicles also. Many pandits will love to visit these areas while having a visit to Sharda temple.
Sharda temple is at a height of 8000 from the sea level and is about 70 miles from Srinagar. The length of the temple is 142 feet and width is 94.6 feet. The outer walls of the temple are 6 ft. wide and 11 ft long. And there are arches with 8 ft. height. It is a very good example of ancient architecture. In ancient times Kashmir as a whole was known as Sharada Peeth due to the temple of Hindu goddess Sree Sharada Devi. Even today, we know that the original script of Kashmiri language is SHARADA script. In "Linguistic Survey of India", George Garrison puts forward the fact that Shina language is the origin of Kashmiri language. Shina Language is spoken in most part of the Gurais (Neelum valley being a part of it). As original script of Kashmiri language is the "Sharada Script and also the Sharada temple as well as Sharada University ruins are present in the Neelum Valley (part of Gurais). More research needs to be done in this direction.
In all probability Sharda temple was constructed somewhere in mid 12th Century, during the reign of Jaisimha by an Aryan Saraswat Brahmin warlord of Kishanganga Valley. According to Al-Biruni, the famous historian of India, Sharada was an important site of pilgrimage. The earliest records in Sharada have been dated to 800 A.D and were found all over northwest India. Also, Gurmukhi, the Punjabi script was based on Sharada script. By origin Kashmiri language is the most southern member of the Dard group of the Pisaca languages. The Pisaca languages are Aryan, but are neither Iranian nor Indo-Aryan. According to George A. Grierson, The speakers of Picasa languages appear to have left the main Aryan body after the great fission which resulted in the Indo-Aryan migration, but before all the typical peculiarities of Iranian speech had fully developed. The immigrants into Kashmir must have been Shins, speaking a language closely allied to the ancestor of the modern Shina. They appear to have dispossessed and absorbed an older non Aryan people, whom local tradition now classes as Nagas, or Snake-gods, and, at Alb, Early_English_period, to have come themselves under the influence of Indo-Aryan immigrants from the south, who entered the valley along the course of the river Jhelum. The language has therefore lost most of its original Pisaca character, and is now a mixed one. Sanskrit has been actively studied for many centuries, and the Kashmiri vocabulary, and even its grammar, is now largely Indian. So much is this the case that, for convenience' sake, it is now frequently classed as belonging to the north-western group of Indo-Aryan languages, instead of as belonging to the Pisaca family as its origin demands. It cannot be said that either classification is wrong. The vocabulary of Kashmiri is, as has been explained, mixed. At its basis it has a large number of words which are also found in the neighbouring Shina, and these are such as connote the most familiar ideas and such as are in most frequent use. Thus, the personal pronouns, the earlier numerals, the words for " father," " mother," " fire," "the sun," are all closely connected with corresponding Shina words. Languages spoken in the Vale of Kashmir and the surrounding hills by origin are Dardic, but Kashmiri has become predominantly Indo-Aryan in character. Reflecting the history of the area, the Kashmiri vocabulary is mixed, containing Dardic, Sanskrit-language, Punjabi, and Persian-language elements.
Looking at the facts & history the time is ripe to setup the Sharda University in the Gurais itself at the bank of Kishenganga River near Baghtor Ismarg. Being only 8 km from the ruins of the ancient Sharada University, the place is perfectly suitable for the modern Sharda University. Besides being a tourist resort & on route of Sharda Peeth, Baghtor Ismarg is idle for research purposes. I must add here that people of Tulail Gurais are the pure Aryan race, and government is promoting the cultural tourism in this part of the valley.
I congratulate respected Governor S K Sinha for putting forward the idea of reviving the ancient Sharda University. The time has come when we should have a detailed research on our rich art and cultural heritage.
Regards
Zahid Samoon (Abraham) ; Management department; University Of Kashmir;
zahid_samoon2000@yahoo.co.in; 9419003183.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Fishery in Gurez has a great economic potential which must be tapped to ensure a sound commercial fish production in the whole region,
writesZAHID SAMOON (ABRAHAM)
Nature has been very kind to the people of Kashmir. State of Jammu and Kashmir, with its diverse climatic zones is bestowed with vast and rich expanse of natural water bodies in the form of snow fed streams, rivers, lakes, sars, springs, marshy areas besides high altitude cold water lakes located at an elevation of above 12000feet. These resources not only add to the splendor of unsurpassed beauty of the state but also form unrivalled rich and diverse fishery resources. The fresh water aquaculture resources in the state comprise of 0.4 lakh kms, vast diversity of climate makes the state suitable for both cold and warm water fishery. Besides the state provides ample opportunity for sport fishery of world famous trout and Mahaseer. Trout farming is one of the oldest forms of commercial fish production. Due to their popularity as a sport fish and as a food fish, trout have been widely distributed and are now cultured in waters around the world. The brown trout is a native of European waters. Like the rainbow trout, it has been widely distributed There is great scope for the development of fishery resources in Gurez valley so as to overcome the prevailing animal protein deficiency in the diet of the local people as well as to generate revenue out of it. There is already a branch of fisheries department in Gurez Valley but it has not been able to work up to the mark for various reasons. If the aquatic resources available in the Gurez valley are properly utilized for the capture and culture of fisheries, the day is not far when we will be in a position to export the fishery products to other parts of the state and country as well. Kishenganga River, 150 Kms in length is famous for having world class trout in it. Average weight of these trout being 24 pounds. There are many varieties of trout and other fishes in it. The most prominent amongst them are: Snow Trout (Shizothorax): It is found predominantly in Tilail area (above40%). They are highly esteemed for their deliciousness, standing second only to trout. Brown trout (Salmo trutta fario L.): 90%. Brown trout is a stenothermal cold water fish which needs fresh water and does not withstand high temperature variations. They like pure, running water rich in oxygen. They spawn in the autumn or at the beginning of winter, that is to say from November to January in the northern hemisphere. The size of brown trout depends on the medium and the richness of its food. Brown trout rarely pass 18 inches in size. Rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri): 10%. Rainbow trout are salmonids best suited for raising industrially and for the production of trout for the table. They are less difficult to feed, less demanding with regards to temperature and the quality of the water. Consequently they are to be found in cold water fish farms throughout the world where they have become the principal salmonids for eating. Shuddgurn: It is in abundance every where in Gurez. Anyour: 1-2% mostly present in aasthan nallah. But don’t think that you can buy any of these fishes in open market of Gurez. Instead of trout you will find fishes imported from outside (usually called Punjabi Gaade) being sold here at high rates. Isn’t it shame for us that although Nature has blessed us with huge resources still we are not able to harness them up to their full potential? Instead we import products from outside state even if they are of lower quality than that are available in our own land. To know the reasons for such a paradox, I went to the branch of fisheries department in Gurez to enquire about sorry state of affairs. I was moved by the startling information I got from there. Many of the fishes thriving in Kishenganga River are affected by diseases of eye and few others are affected by fungal diseases. Mohammed Rafiq, Deputy Inspector, fisheries Department, Gurez while describing the situation says, “All around the world the stocking is done to prevent such diseases and to maintain the No. of fishes. It is done even in every part of Kashmir but it has not been done here till date” He adds that “Stocking should be done by the government after 2-3 years but Kishenganga River has not been stocked from 1943 onwards”. When enquired, why there wasn’t any fisheries farm available for commercial purposes. Mohammed Rafiq said,” “Our department wants to develop fisheries farm here in Gurez at Asthaan nallah from khandyal to fakirpora area. Money has already been granted by Government. About 3 lakhs have been sanctioned so far & out of it 1 lakh is exclusively for land acquisition but land can’t be acquired so far”. He further elaborated, “The farm will be made on 2.17 marlas of land. But Revenue department is not cooperating in the acquisition of farm land. Actually rate of land to be acquired has to be fixed by SDM Gurez and he has fixed it be 60-65 thousand but people want at least 1 lakh per kanal. If the funds are not utilized in time, they will get lapsed. Further SDM has been transferred and presently Tehsildar is discharging the duties of SDM and can’t proceed further in this regard.” When asked why the department is not encouraging the locals to make their own private fisheries farms for commercial purposes. Mohammed Rafiq said,” Government has a plan according to which it will give 1 lakh 20 thousand subsidy to any local if he owns at least 3 kanals for the construction of such a farm. But majority of people (land owners) don’t have Buynama with them which can create hurdles in the overall plan. And even if only one farm would had been made the illegal fishing would had been controlled to a greater extend” But it is unfortunate that there is no general awareness among locals about the prospects of the commercialization of the fisheries products. And when I talked to the general public, many of them didn’t even knew about the plan itself. Fisheries department issues Licenses to anyone as per the rate of 200 rupees per rod for one full day. But if water is muddy not a single fish can be caught. Growth of trout hatcheries need to be promoted and popularized by establishing farms for commercial production. Trout farming in hilly terrain (in nallahs and rivers) should be popularized. Improvement of existing stocks of brown and rainbow trout to produce disease resistant stock should be one of the priority areas. Evolving of diversified means to produce compound pellated feeds for trout especially brown trout is essential for the development of trout in the state. Farmers should be encouraged to organize themselves into cooperative associations so as to enable them to realize higher prices of the fish at competitive rates. Further, in order to cover risks, insurance companies should be involved with simplified procedures for fish insurance schemes. Processing units, cold storage facilities and adequate marketing facilities need to be developed, to reduce losses at, convenient sites. High altitude water bodies which have been untouched so far should be exploited for both capture as well as culture fishery. The introduction of Brown Trout in High mountain lakes like Kiser Sar (lies above the Khandyal village) can prove rewarding, as is indicated by the establishment of trout population in Gang bal lake. Fishing through illegal methods should be completely checked. Carp culture should also be introduced here, carps are considered to be most suitable for pond culture as they feed on plant material or zoo- and phytoplankton, weeds and debris, cement is not necessary for the construction of the fish farm. Carp can even survive in muddy waters. Carp does not need high quality feed like silk worm as is the case with trout; it can survive on cow dung also. While describing the potential of fisheries in Gurez, Deputy inspector, Fisheries Department Gurez, said, “During my service of 30 years in this department, I have never seen a place, with such a huge potential for the benefit of fishery in whole of Kashmir Valley which I have seen here”. Concerned authorities should wake up and remove the various bottlenecks in the way of fisheries department. And government should take various positive steps to make Fisheries a flourishing industry in whole Kashmir. (Zahid Samoon (Abraham) can be mailed at zahid_samoon2000@yahoo.com)

Moses in Kashmir

MOSES (P.B.U.H) IN THE PARADICE OF KASHMIR.
BY ZAHID SAMOON (ABRAHAM)
The term Kashmir historically described the valley just to the south of the western most end of the Himalayan range. Politically, however, the term 'Kashmir' describes a much larger area, which includes the regions of Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh. The northwest portions (Northern Areas and Azad Kashmir) the northeastern portion (Aksai Chin). The main "Vale of Kashmir" is relatively low and very fertile, surrounded by magnificent mountains and fed by many mountain streams flowing from adjoining valleys. It is renowned as one of the most spectacularly beautiful places in the world. Kashmir consists of a wide and beautiful valley, surrounded by tall mountains and is one of the most beautiful places in the world. There have been many controversies regarding its history. Till now many references about the origin of Kashmiri people have been given but controversies are still present. One such theory is about kashmiries being the Lost Tribe of one of the twelve tribes of Bani-Israel
The history of the Kashmir is shrouded in mystery, as is the history of other people in Kashmir. Many researchers are of the opinion that many inhabitants of Kashmir are descendants of the Lost Tribes who were exiled in 722 BC. They wandered along the Silk Road into the countries of the East, Persia and Afghanistan until they reached the Kashmir valley and settled there.
Others say the wanderings began approximately 300 years later. The wanderers settled in Kashmir, kept their traditions until they slowly started idol worship and gradually got converted to Hinduism & ultimately they got converted to Islam when the word of Allah (Islam) reached the valley and thus once again started worshiping the one GOD “ALLAH”. There are 5 to 7 million people here. Generally speaking, they have clearer complexions and are different from the other citizens of India. An Interesting tradition is passed down among the Kashmir people regarding their ancestry from the Lost Tribes of Israel. This tradition is some what supported by extensive literature written by both the people of Kashmir and other scholars. This is supported by various links available from different sources. As some references are as under:
The traveling Arab historian El Bironi in the 12th century wrote, "In the past, permission to enter Kashmir was given only to Jews." The priest Monstrat said that in the time of Vasco da Gama in the 15th century, "all the inhabitants of this area who have been living here since ancient times can trace their ancestry, according to their race and customs, to the ancient Israelites. Their features, their general physical appearance, their clothing, their ways of conducting business, all show that they are similar to the ancient Israelites."
In Kashmir, various places are called with Israeli names, like Har Nevo, Beit Peor, Pisga, and Heshubon. These are all the names in the land of the Ten Tribes of Israel. The same thing is true in the names of people, male names, female names, and names of village. For example, one of the tribes of Kashmir is called Asheriya, which is Asher, the tribe of Dand is Dan, Gadha is Gad, and Lavi is Levi. The Tribe of Shaul is the Hebrew name of King Saul. Musa is Moses, Suliamanish is Solomon. And you also have the tribe of Israel, the tribe of Abri, which are the tribe of Hebrew, and the tribe of Kahana, which is the word for Jewish priest.
The "lost tribes of Israel" are the Muslims of Afghanistan and Kashmir --
The purpose of this article is to show how some of the prophecies with regards to the ‘lost tribes of Israel’ from the Old Testament as well as the New Testament were fulfilled through the Prophet Muhammad. That the ‘lost tribes of Israel’ are Muslim today has important implications, and serves well to support Islam’s case. The Old Testament prophesied that the Promised Prophet, or ‘that one’ in the New Testament, would unite the lesser and fragmented tribes of Israel. Our Christian friends, I’m sure, overlook this point and are quite content not knowing what happened to these tribes, because to discover that these men are today Muslims, would imply that Muhammad was that prophet, and not Jesus. Everything below can be read in various parts of the book ‘Muhammad in World Scriptures – Vol. 1: The Bible’ by Maulana Abdul Haq Vidyarthi.
History of the ten lost tribes of Israel:
There had been only two kings who are called kings of Israel: David and Solomon. After Solomon, in the time of his son Rehoboam, the Israelites broke into two pieces. Only the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin remained under the suzerainty of Rehoboam, whereas the remaining ten tribes rose up in revolt and went over to Jeroboam, who was, during the lifetime of Solomon, his building-engineer. The ten tribes of Israel were cut off and forever separated from the Israelites and were immersed into idolaters and they again began to worship the Golden Calf. They raised their own kingdom in Samaria. In contrast to Judah and Benjamin, they constituted a much bigger fraternity among the Children of Israel. Their rule lasted for 200 years; and then the King of Syria (ancient Assyria) defeated them in 722 BC, scattering and dispersing them. Where this huge horde went is a puzzle that has baffled and bewildered the writers of history. Some surmise, that by means of a tunnel in the earth they reached China; others presume they reached Mongolia and settle there; yet another hypothesis is that they went to some place in Europe. From the Encyclopedia Americana, under the heading 'Lost Ten Tribes': "It was formerly one of the puzzles of history to know what became of the ten tribes. There were several theories, because of the fact that some Jewish monuments were found in China, some writers tracked them to that land. Others found their descendants in India... The general consensus of scientific opinion, however, is that the tribes became absorbed, as subsequent vanished traces have, in neighboring nations, and thus were not lost in the real significance of the term.
So, according to Dr. Bernier, the people of Kashmir and Afghanistan are the same ten lost tribes of the house of Israel. Dr. Francois Bernier, who had been for a long time in the court of the Moghul Emperor Aurangzeb of India, writes in his book Travels in the Moghul Empire: “There are however many marks of Judaism to be found in this country. On entering the Kingdom after crossing the Peer-Panchal Mountains, the inhabitants in the frontier villages struck me as resembling Jews. Their countenances and manners, and that indescribable peculiarity which enables a traveler to distinguish the inhabitants of different nations, all seemed to belong to that ancient people. You are not to ascribe what I say to mere fancy, the Jewish appearance of these villagers having been remarked by our Father, the Jesuit, and some other Europeans long before I visited Kashmir.” (F.Bernier, Travels in the Mogul Empire, trans. Irving Brock, London, 1981, p. 432). George Forster, in his famous Letters on a Journey from Bengal to England, described his visit to Kashmir: “On first seeing the Kashmirians, in their own country, I imagined from their garb, the cast of their countenance which was long and of a grave aspect, and the forms of their beards, that I had come among a nation of Jews.”
Sir Younghusband, who for many years was the Representative of the British Crown to the Court of the Maharaja of Kashmir, wrote: “Here may be seen fine old patriarchal types, just as we picture to ourselves the Israelitish heroes of old. Some, indeed, say… that these Kashmiris are the lost tribes of Israel and certainly, as I have already said, there are real Biblical types to be seen everywhere in Kashmir and especially among the upland villages. Here the Israelitish Shepherd tending his flocks and herds may any day be seen.” (Sir Francis Younghusband, Kashmir, London, 1909, p. 112)
These lost tribes, while living as neighbors to Hindu idolaters, adopted their customs and habits. These Jews believed in the Unity of God, and this Unity in the terminology of scholars of religion is called Henotheism, i.e. the belief that "our God is one, but other nations have their own Gods; our God is exclusively our own, having nothing to do with other peoples." In this basis they hold that as long as they live in the land of their Lord, Jehovah, they should render obedience to Him, but when they immigrate to another place and take up their residence among other people, they should worship and adore the God of that land. So we find that in the beginning, when they founded their own kingdom in Samaria, having been separated from Solomon's son. The population of Kashmir, thus, consists of two nations, the 'Kashmiri Kashyapi', who trace their ancestry to the Hindu Rishi, Kashyap, and the 'Ban Mash' who have migrated into Kashmir from outside; and although the Hindus did not absorb them, they had to adopt, according to their own belief, the worship of Hindu gods and their habits and customs.
My final point regarding the fact that the people of Kashmir are Israelites is that the names of cities of Afghanistan and Kashmir have the same names as places mentioned in the Bible; i.e. they are Hebrew names. We have 'Gilgit' for the Biblical 'Golgotha', and 'Poonch' for 'Phenice.' The meaning of 'Kabul (the capital of Afghanistan)' in the Hebrew language (Cabul) is a 'dirty city', or alternatively ‘displeasing city. There is also Chah-i-Babel (the well of Babylon) near Islamabad; and Takht-i-Sulaiman (the Throne of Solomon) in the vicinity of the temple of Shankaracharya.
‘Kashmir’ is a Hebrew Word:
Furthermore, Kashmiri or Kashahmiri is a Hebrew word and an attributive name of the Israelites. The root is Kas(h)ah, similar to the Arabic kashiya. In Hebrew it means fleshy and plump, and the Bible itself has conferred this name on the Israelites, and in the idiomatic tradition of the Bible, ‘becoming fat’ means to ‘become an idolater’ – see Deuteronomy, 31:20,Nehemiah 9:25-26, 1 Samuel 2:29-30 for reference. In the same place in the Bible, the Israelites have also been called Yeshurun or Jeshurun, and both these names indicate two contradictory qualities of the Israelites. Yeshurun has been derived from the yashar or yashar, which means the follower of truth or worshipper of the One True God. The following texts of the Bible may read in this connection:
“But Jeshurun waxed fat, and kicked; you waxed fat, you grew thick, you became sleek; then he forsook God who made him, and scoffed at the Rock of his salvation.” (Deuteronomy 32:15) Yeshurun or Jeshurun, in this text, is the name of the Israelites and signifies here a person who worships the One True God (Gesenius and Brown, A Hebrew and English Lexicon.) But this Jeshur or Yashar had been called Ka(s)ha or Kashyapa when he began to worship, instead of Lord God Jehovah, other gods and idols of the Hindus, and coming into foreign countries thought no more of and forgot Jehovah. Just to support my point, one of the most popular mountain passes in Afghanistan is called Khyber Pass. Khyber is a Hebrew word meaning a Fort.
A Few Prophecies from the Bible Concerning the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel:
1. Jacob on His Death Bed Confers Blessings on Joseph: “Of these 10 lost tribes, the most honored and renowned was the tribe of Joseph from among the Children of Ephraim; only two tribes, Judah and Benjamin, had been left in Palestine. Joseph’s was the tribe of which it was written: “Rachel is weeping for her children.” (Jeremiah 31:15. Cf. Matthew 2:18).
Her lamentation was warranted because all the hopes of the Jews were linked with this tribe. Jacob, when he laid on his death-bed, conferred most of his blessings on Joseph's tribe and uttered a prophecy about their prosperity and success (Genesis 49:22-24), and Moses too, in the last moments of his life invoked for this tribe blessings, both spiritual and temporal: About Joseph he said: “May the Lord bless his land with the precious dew from heaven above and with deep waters that lie below; with the best the sun brings forth and the finest the moon can yield; with the choicest gifts of the ancient mountains and the fruitfulness of the everlasting hills; with the best gifts of the earth and its fullness and the favor of him who dwelt in the burning bush. Let all these rest on the head of Joseph, on the brow of the prince among his brothers. In majesty he is like a first born bull; his horns are the horns of a wild ox. With them he will gore the nations, even those at the ends of the earth. Such are the ten thousands of Ephraim; such are the thousands of Manasseh.” (Deuteronomy 33:13-17) How could it be that such a precious gem, as Joseph was, should have been abandoned and left in darkness, and the word of God should have failed in this case? It is a matter of fact that these ten tribes, including the Children of Joseph, the Sons of Ephraim, came to and settled in Afghanistan and Kashmir. When Jacob, on his death-bed also conferred blessings on Joseph’s two sons Ephraim and Manasseh, he gave Ephraim the younger son more blessings. Joseph did not like it and held up his father’s hand saying” “Not so, my father; for this one is the first born; put your right hand upon his head.” (Genesis 48:18). But the father refused, and set Ephraim before Manasseh. As a result, Ephraim’s dynasty became so much dignified and renowned that is name became synonymous with the ruler ship of Israel. The fundamental question arises, how is it possible that this promised son and his tribe could become non-existent and extinct? If these tribes had been Christians, it could be said that their shepherd was Jesus; but since they came into the fold of Islam their shepherd and King, the Promised David, was the Holy Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H), not Jesus (P.B.U.H). Furthermore, God sent His prophet, Jesus, to seek and find them, and bring them back to the religion of their fathers.
There are also 50-75 names of places in Kashmir, which are in fact the Hebrew names that ancient Israelites were very familiar with. There is a place called Samaryah, which is Samaria. Mamre is Mamre, Pishgah is Pisgah, Nabudaal is Mt. Nevo, Bushan is Bashan, Gilgit is Gilgal, Heshba is Heshbon, Amunah is Amon, Gochan is Goshen, Median-pura is Midian, and Guzana is Gozan which is a place name in Assyria and the very place where the Ten Tribes of Israel were deported.
There is yet another tradition in connection with King Solomon according to which even King Solomon reached the Kashmir Valley and through his wisdom aided the people of Kashmir by successfully regulating the Jehlum River. This tradition is also connected to a place called Solomon's throne, which is situated above the capital of Kashmir, Srinagar. "Get thee up into this Mountain Abarim, unto Mount Nebo... and die in the mount whether thou goest up ... yet thou shalt see the land before thee; but thou shalt not go thither unto the land which I give to the Children of Israel" (Deut., 32: 49-52) ."And when thou hast seen it, thou also shalt be gathered unto thy people" (Nu. 27: 13) "So Moses the servant of the Lord died there ... buried him in a valley in the land ...” (Deut., 34: 5-6).
These verses record that in obedience to the Divine Command Moses ascended to the top of Mount Nebo and from there he viewed the Land of Promise and thereafter he died at that spot and God buried him. But according to the Christian belief, God not only buried him but buried his sepulchre also.
The Jewish legend surrounds the death of Moses with mystery. It is asserted in the Jewish history called the Assumption of Moses that Michael came into conflict with Satan as to the disposal of the body of Moses. This legend is also referred to in the Epistles of Jude (Jude: 5-9). According to eastern Jewish legends when the Israelites murmured and talked of returning to Egypt, Yahweh in his wrath threatened to destroy them, and to make Moses and his clan (Mosa Kheo into a nation mightier and greater than they (Nu. 14: 12). Yahweh decided that only Moses should with his posterity possess the Promised Land. Moses should have and did thenceforth disappear and went to that land, but the printed tradition alleged that a cloud surrounded him and he disappeared and God had taken him alive into heaven on account of his piety (Jewish Ency., Art. Moses, 9: 53). In a passage from Homily 26 in the Epistle to the Hebrews (Ch. 3), St. John Chrysostom wrote: "But tell me, do not the bones of Moses himself lie in a far off land in the East.”
But, ignoring Jewish traditions and Christian beliefs, it is obvious that, if Kashmir was the Land of Promise, Moses must have visited the place and his tomb must be somewhere in Kashmir. There can be no possibility of any doubt if it is established that Moses did die in Kashmir. The traditions of Kashmir, written and oral assert that Moses did visit Kashmir and died there. A few of the historians of Kashmir as, Abdul Qadir bin Qaziul-Quzat Wazil Ali Khan, in his Hashmat-i-Kashmir, writes: "Moses came to Kashmir and people believed in him. Subsequently they continued to believe in him, others did not. He died and was buried here. The people of Kashmir call his tomb the Shrine of the Prophet of the Book" (Hashmat-i-Kashmir, ETR.A. Society of Bengal. MS. 192).
In Tarikh-i-Azami the following passage occurs: "And this Sang Bibi was also a renowned hermitess and excelled men in meditation and prayer. Near to her tomb is a place which is known as the sepulchre of Moses, the Prophet of God (P.B.U.H), and people who know assert that many benefits are derived from that place" (Khwaja Muhammad Azam, Tarikh-i-Azami, 84).
In Guldasta-i-Kashmir it is recorded: "Muslims call this land a replica of heaven on earth and also named it the Garden of Solomon. There are many shrines in the land. They say that Hazrat Sulaiman came here and that Hazrat Musa passed through and died in the land" (Pundit Har Gopal, Guldasta-i-Kahmir, 17).
Similar references are to be found in Wajeez-ut-Tawarikh (Wajeez-ut-Tawarikh, Vol. 1: 28) and Tarikh-i-Hasan (Tarikh-i-Hasan, Vol. 3: 74). Among European travelers and writers, Francis Bernier was the first to note this fact. In his fourth ground for the belief that Kashmiris were descendants of Israel, he said: "The fourth ground is the belief that Moses died in this city of Kashmir and that this took place within a league of it" (Bernier, Travels in India, 174).
George Moore, in his The Lost Tribes, says: "Moses himself came amongst them to teach them the worship of one God" (George Moore, The Lost Tribes, 137).
Lt. -Col. HD Torrens writes: "There is a belief too; that Moses died in the Capital of Kashmir and that he is buried near it" (Torrens, Lt.-Col., H.D., Travels in Ladakh, Tartary and Kashmir, 268).
Mrs. Harvey, citing Badi-ud-Din as her authority, states:"According to one eminent authority Kashmir was inundated on account of the relapse of the inhabitants to idolatry, after having been taught the worship of One God by Moses, who died there and whose tomb is by some said to be still pointed out" (Mrs.Harvey, The Adventures of a Lady in Tartary, Tibet, China and Kashmir, Vol. 2: 154).
A place called (Aham Sharif) is located about eight miles from Behatpoor (Bandipur) from where a village called Hudabal is present at some distance where tomb of Moses is thought to be present. The tomb itself is in a quadrangular enclosure and in it there are three other covered tombs. One of them is of Sang Bibi, the hermitess, and the other two are of her disciples. All these three tombs, like Muslim graves, are in the north-south direction. The fourth tomb is believed to be of Moses, which, like Jewish graves, is in the east-west direction.
The tomb of Moses has two trees on either side. They were planted about 400 years ago by Hazrat Makhdoom Shaikh Hamza of Kashmir who prayed there for forty days near the tomb of Prophet Moses. He said that he could smell the aroma of prophethood from the tomb.
The tomb of Moses is on Nebu baal (Mount Nebu). From this place Behatpoor (Bandipur), Sin Betour (second Mount Sinai) is visible. Hashba, Pisgah and Maqam-i-Musa, the Place of Moses, are within a short distance from it. There is considerable material in support of the tradition that Moses came to Kashmir and died there. Musa is a very popular name among the inhabitants of Kashmir and many places are also named after him. Thus there is Gund-i-Khalil or Gund-i-Musa in Awantipur. Sir Aurel Stein mentions Kohna-i-Musa near Shadipur (Stein, Sir Aurel, Rajatarangini, Vol. 1: 70) and Rampur (Stein, Sir Aurel, The Ancient Geography of Kashmir, 166). There are four Maqam-i-Musa, the place of (rest) of Moses in Kashmir. One is near Auth Wattu in Handwara Tehsil. This place is also known as Ayat Maula, the Sign of God. Moses came to the valley from this direction and prayed at this spot for forty days. The second is at the junction of the two rivers Jhelum and Sindh near Shadipur. It is sometimes known as Kohna-i-Musa and Stein mentions it by this name. The third is at Pisgah and the fourth is near Bandipur.
There is Sang-i-Musa - the stone of Moses - at Bijbehara. It is locally known as Ka Ka Pal - the stone of Ka Ka. The Ladakhis call Moses Ka Ka. This stone of Moses is also mentioned in Rajatarangini. It weighs about 110 pounds.
If we turn to the Holy Quran we can find material for maintaining that Moses did come to Kashmir. To begin with, Israelites are assured that they will live in the Land of Promise after they had been persecuted (The Holy Quran 7: 137). Consequently, the Israelites had to enter the Land of Promise after their captivity and subsequent release.
The meeting of Moses with Khwaja Khizr is an incident, which lends support to the fact that Moses did come to Kashmir. We are told that Moses with his servant reached the junction of the two rivers (Ibid. 18: 60). The phrase, Majma-ul-Bahrain, does not indicate merely a junction of two rivers, but it really signifies the fact that the two rivers must lose their identity as if they had fallen into the sea. The junction of the rivers Jhelum and Sindh (it must not be confused with the Indus) is at Shadipur and after a few miles they fall into Wullar Lake. At this junction, and in midstream, is a rock on which a platform has been made. It is known as Makam-i-Musa, the resting-place of Moses, and sometimes it is called Kohna-i-Musa, the corner stone of Moses. Thus Moses with his companion came upon this junction and "they took refuge on the rock'' (Ibid. 18: 63). And it is from this place that they retraced their steps (Ibid. 18: 64).
On his return journey Moses meets a person, not named in the Book, upon whom God had bestowed mercy and taught him of His knowledge (Ibid. 18: 65). Commentators agree that this person was Khwaja Khizr. Moses asked permission to follow him: "So they went (their way) until when they embarked in the boat, he made a hole in it. (Moses) said: Have you made a hole in it to drown its inmates? Certainly you have done a grievous thing" (Ibid. 18: 71).
The Holy Quran then mentions the reason for this extraordinary conduct of Khwaja Khizr: "As for the boat, it belonged to (some) poor men who worked on the river and I wished that I should damage it, and there was behind them a king who seized every boat by force" (Ibid. 18: 79).
Nalsain (Wilson, H.H., Hiscout, Ancient History of Kashmir, 81), King of Kashmir, according to the calculations of Wilson, was a contemporary of Moses. He was a wicked and cruel king. During his reign Kashmir was invaded and there was also a rebellion in the land. Nalsain took forcible possession of all the good boats so that he might cut off the means of communication of his enemies. This is a fact of history and Khwaja Khizr was made aware of the evil intention of Nalsain. Khwaja Khizr, like Moses, is a very popular name among Kashmiris and Khwaja, meaning Master, is prefixed to the names of respectable Kashmiris.
Josephus records that Moses took leave of his people and went to Mount Nebu, "when a cloud suddenly stood over him and he disappeared'' (Josephus, Antiquities, 4: 8, 48). Later on a belief was set up that Moses did not die but had in fact been taken up to heaven like Elijah (Jewish Ency., Art. Moses). But here again, as in the case of Jesus, the Holy Prophet MUHAMMAD (P.B.U.H) disclosed the real truth. He said: "When Moses' death approached he prayed to God to be permitted to see the Promised Land." This prayer was granted. Hazrat Abu Hurairah goes on to report that the Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) added: "He (Moses) died there. If I were there I could have pointed out to you his tomb on the path of a rugged hill'' (Bukhari, Vol. 2, 16).
Personally when I asked about the history of tomb to one of the old man who is the local resident (Sonna-walla-telii) of a near by village. He confirmed that they have heard from their ancestors about some linkage of tomb with HAZRAT MUSA (P.B.U.H). On further questioning he told me the following story which there ancestors used to tell them…that once upon a time an outsider had come to bandipora. He was having some kind of severe ailment. This outsider used to pray a lot and one day he saw Khwaja Khizr in his dreams. Khwaza Khizr told him to build fencing around the tomb at Hudabal. As the outsider started fencing around this tomb his ailment was cured. Even today the local people go this tomb and pray to Allah. They believe the tomb to be of HAZRAT MUSA (P.B.U.H).
Rather though than this being an Israelite influence in Kashmir at the time of Moses, it was more likely a Jewish influence about a millennium later, consequent upon the Babylonian Captivity, with a subsequent Jewish influx into Persia, Afghanistan and Kashmir. Perhaps this immigrant people, like the Afghanis who Kersten says (p. 56) "trace their lineage back to King Saul of Israel and call themselves "Ben-I-Israel"," were in fact scattered members of Saul's tribe of Benjamin taken captive from Judah. The Book of Esther (11:2) indeed records Benjaminites living in Persia's capital of Susa; Queen Esther herself being one of them. Apropos to this situation. Kersten tells on p. 58:
The inhabitants of Kashmir are different from the other peoples of India in every respect. Their way of life, their behavior, their morals, their character, their clothing, their language, customs and habits are all of a type that might be described as typically Israelite. Like present-day Israelis, the Kashmiris do not use fat for frying and baking: they use only oil. Most Kashmiris like boiled fish, called fari, eaten in remembrance of the time before their Exodus from Egypt ' (Numbers 11:5).
Butchers' knives in Kashmir are made in the half-moon shape typical of the Israelites, and even the rudders of the boat people (Hanjis) are of the similarly typical heart shape.
The men wear distinctive caps on their heads. The clothing of the old women of Kashmir (pandtanis) is very similar to that of Jewish women, and like them they also wear headscarves and laces. Like young Jewish girls, the girls of Kashmir dance in two facing columns with linked arms, moving together forwards and backwards to the rhythm. It is called rof.
Many of the older graves in Kashmir (i.e., pre Islamic) are aligned in the east-west orientation, whereas Islamic graves normally point north south. A great number of such graves are to be found in Haran, Rajpura, Syed Bladur Sahib, Kukar Nagh and Awantipura. In the cemetery at Bijbihara, the place where the bath and stone of Moses are located.
Moses' burial is thought by the locals to have occurred in Kashmir in that defined region that we discussed earlier in connection with Mount Nebo. And Solomon's Temple is also said to have been built here In Kashmir. P. 49: "Kashmir is still known among the local Muslim population as Bagh-i-Suleiman, the 'Garden of Solomon'."
"And Moses said unto them, I am 120 years old this day; I can no more come in and go out, so the Lord has said I shall not go over this Jordon." Moses died in Moab, and was buried in the valley opposite Beth Peor." Deu.31; 2. The words Beth (river) Peor (gap or opening) become Bandipore in Kashmir, and Moses' grave is believed to be in Bandipore, on a hillside between two mountains and through the gap the Jhelum River passes. One can sit on the edge of the grave and gaze down at the river far below. Here is a large opening (oriented east to west) surrounded by rocks. One rock slab is planted deeply on end, with just a small end visible above the dirt (typical of Hebrew graves in the Himalayas). On one edge of the grave are wind horses, also called prayer flags, which indicate that local people still make their way up here, say prayers, and tear a piece of their clothing to leave as an offering.
Even after having references in support of kashmiries being the lost tribe of Bani-Israel. Yet we can’t come to any conclusion, as there are a lot of missing links in between. But surely it is one aspect of a long & unstudied history of magnificent vale of Kashmir.
Before concluding I will like to say that Allah best knows all that is present & all that has passed. Still we have to search for the reality in real sense. I hope that in future some research will be done in this direction also so that misconceptions are rectified.
Zahid Samoon (Abraham)

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Leadership Crisis

NEED
Who will fill the vacuum, writes Zahid Samoon (Abraham)

Where have all our leaders gone? They sometimes appear to be an endangered species caught in a whirl of events and circumstances. Our quality of life depends on the quality of our leaders. As a person cannot function without a brain, so a society cannot function without leaders. A leader is always responsible for the effectiveness of organizations and institutions of the Nation. He always leads and motivates the nation towards a goal of prosperity. When we try to analyze any nation in the contemporary world, we usually judge that nation on the basis of the people who represent them. Here I am not talking about the people who govern a country but the people who represent a nation. They are the persons who act as a role model for their people. Leaders have always been a guide to take the nation out of ignorance and darkness towards glory and success. The History of Kashmir is replete with the leaders of high calibre who have inspired the people for ages. Although there is no dearth of talent and capability in our young generation, but what we lack is the proper guidance to tap that talent so that they are moulded into better leaders for future. Today Kashmir is facing the leadership crises. Genuine leadership is the need of the hour. The crisis of leadership in Jammu and Kashmir is proving to be the main stumbling block in the resolution of Kashmir Issue and other related issues. We need leaders of eminence and stature with a broad vision who can lead us in the right direction of prosperity and restore the past glory of Kashmir in every field. Presently the signs of a leadership crisis are alarming and persuasive. There is a widespread loss of faith in our major institutions, be it social or religious institutions. Incredible political and global changes are creating great confusion, and joblessness is playing havoc with the morals and innovative capabilities of our youth. But these dangers raise another, yet more urgent, threat: the failure of leadership to address these concerns. None of the other problems we face can be solved without effective leadership. It seems that there is an unconscious conspiracy to discourage and suppress genuine leadership. As a nation, and as individuals, we fear taking risks. The context of our work and personal lives reinforces a set of common values, attitudes and perceptions that discourages us from standing out in a crowd – and that calls for playing it safe. We believe in blaming others for our failures and setbacks. We try to see the negative side of everything, but don’t do a bit to rectify it. We blame others for our own suffering. Take the example of Dal Lake. Who is responsible for its present state? People need to wake up and start taking responsibility before it is too late. It is each individual’s responsibility to stand out in the crowd. At present no single leader can save the day. Truly successful leadership today requires team work, collaboration, diversity, innovation, and cooperation. I am calling for a continuum of leadership that includes indirect leadership exerted through support and networking. On that continuum, each of us can find a means of expressing ourselves. Each one of us is capable of creating ourselves as effective leaders. The learning process is one that includes self-critical examination, taking risks and then reaching goals. It also includes learning about the context that limits the full expression of leadership. This context is inherited from our youth and shapes our current view of ourselves. As long as it remains invisible to us, we cannot shift our thinking or our behavior to fill the leadership gap. If we really want to stand united and emerge as a prosperous nation, then we have to start working from the very basics. We have to change our modus operandi towards various things. So, take responsibilities and be leaders.
(The writer is from The Business School, University of Kashmir. Feedback at
zahid_samoon2000@yahoo.co.in)